House Bill 5312 ,Who Will Win and Who Will Lose?

When Governor Malloy wrote Executive Order 9 & 10 he didn't have the disabled community in mind. It's up to the voters to hold our politicians accountable!

I realize that by voicing my opinion I am opening myself up to judgment and criticism.  However, certain issues are important and sometimes bringing an issue to the forefront helps everyone to truly understand what is at stake.

Politics are not my forte. I have a difficult time understanding the procedures that are followed and I have never been one for political rhetoric. However, when an issue strikes home, I tend to rise to the occasion and try to figure it all out.  Especially when it all sounds so odd.

Last year, after the legislature rejected a law to allow the forced unionization of personal care attendants and day care workers, Governor Malloy circumvented this decision with  Executive Orders 9 & 10. Legislators are challenging the constitutionality of these orders in court. Last week, House Bill 5312 passed in the House and is now headed for the Senate floor. Although I have asked some very basic questions I have not been able to get any specific answers from my senator.  Hopefully by bringing this issue to the public, we will get some answers and people’s awareness will be raised.

For the purpose of my statements, I am speaking more about the PCA issue. I have first-hand experience with this program as both of my daughters employ PCA’s to help them stay integral members of society. They are paid $12.50 per hour, most of them are college students and work part-time. Given the nature of their duties, PCAs inevitably become extended members of our family and not just employees.

PCA’s are personal care assistants. It is part of a program that allows disabled consumers to hire their own assistants to help them with basic daily living tasks.  Some of these tasks are showering, getting out of bed, preparing meals, taking medications, the list goes on.

A Medicaid waiver funds this federal program and there are many requirements to allow a consumer to become part of this program. 

I am concerned that if the bill is passed in the Senate and the unions take over bargaining for the PCA’s, where will the additional money come from for union dues, higher wages and health care benefits? While the bill forces unionization, it fails to pay for these added costs. I fear that these costs are going to be hoisted on our disabled consumers, many of whom have little means to pay for it.

Additionally, I do not understand how Governor Malloy could write in an Executive Order when the bill was clearly shut down by our legislators during the last session. Our legislatures are the very people put into office to be a voice for us. I know we met numerous times with Representative Candelora to give him our feelings on the issue. He listened, asked questions and then acted on our behalf.

Another important piece of this puzzle is how the union is treating people. They have been harassing PCA’s, barraging them with mail and set up an unfair practice for voting. It is very concerning to find out that if you didn’t vote, that was counted as a yes vote for the union. Additionally, if you voted incorrectly, it was also a yes vote. So this body of people voted the union in, but we really don’t know if yes was the general consensus or if most people didn’t vote or voted incorrectly.

If the union is handling the voting and rallying of people with such disrespect, how do people feel they will be treated if the Senate passes Bill 5312? House Bill 5312 slashes the safety net for our most vulnerable population. If the bill is raised in the Senate, I hope Senator Meyer stands up for our disabled population and votes No.

If you believe in our passion against this bill, please consider calling your Senator and asking them to vote no for HB 5312. 


This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Rep. Vin Candelora April 30, 2012 at 06:04 PM
Thank you Mary for letting us all know the effects of these laws. I admire you advocacy and determination. We need to stop this bill from going forward in the Senate.
Grant T April 30, 2012 at 10:26 PM
The Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities at the UN noted that the most important factors for success was the right to Self Determination. Self Determination means that person with disabilities by themselves or through their supports can determine how they will spend their own benefits, where they will live and make these choices by themselves. You have not understood the public sentiment for this opposition at all. They do not need Governor appointed panels to speak on their behalves. The legislature has the power to appropriate more monies. Michigan just repealed the law, under SB1018. Maine, PA, and VA. are in the process of reversing these processes. The SEIU skimmed millions of dollars in the States for union dues. Research on Statewide Union Contracts will show that there has been no benefit gained in having the SEIU. This is public information. Oregon: $10.20/hour minus dues. WA: $10.03/hour up to $11.07/ hr. after 14k hours worked minus union dues. MI averaged $9.55/hr. minus 2.5% union dues. Under the PCA Waiver the wage is as high as $12.38/hour. The SEIU contract wage in MA is $12.48/hour, minus 2% union dues, and a $6.50 per biweekly pay period minimum dues. CT ALREADY FARES BETTER. SEIU is not the answer. We all want to respect the dignity for workers and self determination of those whom are served. Grant T.
Nikki Serrante May 01, 2012 at 12:34 AM
Yeah mary! you said it.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »